The rush to import goods is straining supply chains now but could leave carriers and warehouses scrambling later
A small flick at the end of a whip creates a big snap. In supply chains, a small change in customer demand can trigger much larger swings in orders, production, and shipping further up the chain. Economists call this the bullwhip effect -- and it can cause big headaches for manufacturers, carriers, and retailers alike.
How It Works
The bullwhip effect follows a familiar cycle:
* A sudden event, such as a new tariff, sales promotion, or unexpected shortage, changes demand.
* Buyers are placing larger orders than usual to get ahead of the change.
* Manufacturers ramp up production to meet the surge.
* Shipping volumes spike as companies rush to move goods.
* Inventories pile up, often beyond what's needed.
* Orders then drop sharply, creating a slowdown.
The result is a swing from "too busy" to "too slow" in a matter of weeks.
Causes Beyond Tariffs
While new tariffs can trigger buying frenzies, they're not the only driver:
* Forecast errors: Inaccurate demand forecasting can ripple upstream.
* Long lead times: Delays in production or transportation magnify small changes.
* Promotions and discounts: Temporary demand spikes distort long-term needs.
* Lack of visibility: Limited data sharing between suppliers and retailers increases overreactions.
Lessons From the Past
The 2018-2019 U.S.-China trade tensions showed how tariff deadlines can swing volumes, with ports like Los Angeles and Long Beach experiencing record surges followed by steep declines. More recently, the COVID-19 pandemic saw panic buying of toilet paper and PPE create the same kind of spike-and-drop pattern, leaving excess stock after the surge.
How Companies Can Respond
While the bullwhip effect can't be eliminated, companies can soften its impact by:
* Improving demand forecasting with real-time data.
* Sharing information across suppliers, carriers, and retailers.
* Keeping lead times shorter where possible.
* Avoiding knee-jerk order changes that create bigger swings upstream.
MORE SUPPLY CHAIN 101: What Are Smart Warehouses and How Do They Work? | What is Reshoring and Why Does It Matter? | What Is Resilience and Why Does It Matter? | What is Blockchain and How is it Transforming Logistics? | What's the Difference Between LTL and FTL Shipping? | What's the Difference Between 3PL, 4PL, and 5PL? | What are Rare Earth Minerals and Why Do They Matter? | How a War With Iran Could Disrupt Global Trade | What's the Difference Between a Robot and a Cobot?